I was really iffy on buying this one because of the sizing, I thought it would be one size so I was lost. I ordered a XL to 2X because it said that was for my pant size. But, it was huge on me, so I'll I have to say is it stretches out a lot so a S-L should be totally fine to fit in. I'll give it 4 stars because it is really nice but that sizing was confusing to me and I'm a pant size 14 and the XL was wayy huge.
The drawstring was a little tricky for me, but apart from that, I'm well satisfied. This petticoat does its job!